Browse
Log in / Register
Share
For businesses and serious haulers, the 2017 Ram 2500 Tradesman emerged as the top value choice in a head-to-head comparison of base-model, three-quarter-ton pickup trucks, offering the best combination of payload capacity, power, and standard features for its price.
Often overlooked in favor of bestselling half-tons, three-quarter-ton pickups serve a critical role for contractors, municipalities, and families needing serious towing and payload capability without the extreme cost of a one-ton model. To determine which truck delivers the best value, we evaluated four 2017 regular-cab, V-8 powered work trucks: the Chevrolet Silverado 2500 WT, Ford Super Duty F-250 XL, Nissan Titan XD, and Ram 2500 Tradesman. Based on our assessment experience, the winner provided superior capability right out of the box.
All four trucks were base work-truck (WT/XL/Tradesman) trims with 8-foot beds, leveling the playing field for a pure value comparison. The table below summarizes the key specifications and starting prices, which include the destination charge.
| Truck Model | Engine | Horsepower | Torque (lb-ft) | Starting Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chevrolet Silverado 2500 WT | 6.0L V-8 | 360 hp | 380 | $37,040 |
| Ford Super Duty F-250 XL | 6.2L V-8 | 385 hp | 430 | $38,220 |
| Nissan Titan XD S | 5.6L V-8 | 390 hp | 394 | $36,115 |
| Ram 2500 Tradesman | 6.4L HEMI V-8 | 410 hp | 429 | $36,795 |
The Nissan Titan XD was the least expensive but occupies a unique place in the market, positioned between a half-ton and a traditional three-quarter-ton pickup. The Ford F-250 was the most expensive but also featured a sophisticated high-strength steel frame with an aluminum body to reduce weight.
Payload capacity—the maximum weight a truck can carry in its cabin and bed—is a critical metric for work trucks. The Gross Vehicle Weight Rating (GVWR), which is the maximum allowable total weight of the truck plus its cargo, is the official determinant of a truck's payload. In our testing, the Ram 2500 had the highest GVWR and the most payload capacity, making it the standout for heavy hauling.
The Ford F-250's torque advantage (430 lb-ft) was notable for towing heavy trailers. However, the Ram 2500’s 6.4-liter HEMI V-8, producing 410 horsepower and 429 lb-ft of torque, delivered strong, responsive power across various conditions. The Nissan Titan XD, while powerful on paper, struggled with acceleration during loaded track testing and posted lower fuel economy figures.
Despite their minimalistic interiors, these work trucks included essential features for productivity and connectivity.
Based on our assessment of payload, power, and included features, the 2017 Ram 2500 Tradesman represented the best value for a dedicated work truck. It delivered the highest payload capacity, a potent engine, and important work-ready features like integrated trailer brake control at a competitive price of $36,795.
The Ford F-250 XL is a strong, technologically advanced contender for those who prioritize maximum torque and advanced construction. The Chevrolet Silverado 2500 WT is an excellent choice for buyers who want modern infotainment in a proven, reliable package. The Nissan Titan XD is a budget-friendly option for those whose hauling needs fall between a half-ton and three-quarter-ton truck.
For any buyer, the key takeaway is to prioritize the truck’s Gross Vehicle Weight Rating (GVWR) and payload capacity to ensure it can handle your specific tools and materials daily. While creature comforts are limited in this class, the right truck is a powerful business investment.
